Second Program Review Comments

The comments on this page were submitted by stakeholders as part of the now-completed Second Program Review process, following a series of stakeholder meetings.

For materials from these meetings and more information about program review, see the Second Program Review page.

Sept. 25, 2017 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
Ceres Comments PDF 10.16.17
The City of New York Comments PDF 10.16.17
Collaborative for RGGI Progress Comments PDF 10.16.17
Dynegy Comments PDF 10.16.17
EEANY Comments PDF 10.16.17
Joint Comments (4 Industry Organizations) PDF 10.16.17
Joint Comments (35 Environmental Organizations) PDF 10.16.17
Joint Comments (16 Environmental Justice Organizations) PDF 10.16.17
NJ Department of Environmental Protection Comments PDF 10.16.17
NYISO Comments PDF 10.16.17
Physicians for Social Responsibility (PSR) Comments PDF 10.16.17
Sierra Club Member Comments (2,051 Individuals) PDF 10.16.17

 

Jun. 27, 2017 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
The Analysis Group Comments PDF 7.17.17
Ceres Comments PDF 7.17.17
The City of New York Comments PDF 7.17.17
Collaborative for RGGI Progress Comments PDF 8.3.17
ConEdison Comments PDF 7.17.17
E2 Comments PDF 7.28.17
EEANY Comments PDF 8.3.17
IETA Comments PDF 7.28.17
Individual Comments (10 Individuals) PDF 7.17.17
Individual Comments (Additional, 2 Individuals) PDF 7.28.17
Joint Comments (45 Environment and Health Organizations) PDF 7.17.17
Joint Comments (5 Environmental Justice Organizations) PDF 7.17.17
Joint Comments (36 Environment and Environmental Justice Organizations) PDF 8.3.17
Joint Comments (ACE NY, AEE Institute, NECEC) PDF 7.17.17
Mercuria Energy America, Inc. Comments PDF 7.17.17
The Nature Conservancy Comments PDF 7.17.17
PSEG Comments PDF 7.28.17
Resources for the Future Comments PDF 7.17.17
Sierra Club Members and Supporters' Comments (7,557 Individuals) PDF 7.17.17

 

Apr. 20, 2017 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
American Lung Association of the Northeast Comments PDF 5.3.17
Castleton Commodities Merchant Trading, LP PDF 5.3.17
Individual Comments (32 Individuals) PDF 5.3.17
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) Comments PDF 6.6.17
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) Additional Comments PDF 7.17.17
Joint Comments (38 Environment and Health Organizations) PDF 5.3.17
Joint Comments (ACE NY, AEE Institute, NECEC) PDF 5.3.17
Joint Letter (51 Organizations) PDF 6.14.17
Massachusetts Group Comments (117 Individuals) PDF 5.3.17
Mercuria Energy America, Inc. Comments PDF 5.3.17
Mothers Out Front Member Comments (6 Individuals) PDF 5.3.17
NRDC Comments PDF 6.6.17
Physicians for Social Responsibility Member Comments (207 Individuals) PDF 5.3.17
Physicians for Social Responsibility Additional Member Comments (13 Individuals) PDF 6.6.17
Rep. Marjorie Shepardson (NH House of Representatives) Comments PDF 5.3.17
Roger Caiazza Comments PDF 6.14.17
Sierra Club Letter (2,135 Signatories) PDF 5.3.17
Sierra Club Personalized Member Comments (433 Members) PDF 5.3.17
Vitol, Inc. Comments PDF 5.3.17

      

Feb. 8, 2017 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
Advanced Energy Economy Institute (AEEI) and Northeast Clean Energy Council (NECEC) Comments PDF 2.22.17
Collaborative for RGGI Progress Comments PDF 3.1.17
Environment America Federation Comments PDF 2.22.17
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) Comments PDF 3.1.17
Joint Comments (14 Environment and Health Commenters) PDF 2.22.17
Mercuria Energy America, Inc. Comments PDF 2.22.17
Robert E. Rutkowski Comments PDF 3.1.17
Vitol, Inc. Comments PDF 2.22.17

 

Nov. 21, 2016 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
Advanced Energy Economy Institute (AEEI) and Northeast Clean Energy Council (NECEC) Comments PDF 12.1.16
Ag Methane Advisors Comments PDF 12.1.16
BioUrja Nehme Commodities Comments PDF 12.23.16
Burlington Electric Department Comments PDF 12.16.16
City of New York, Mayor's Office of Recovery and Resiliency Comments PDF 12.1.16
Climate Law and Policy Project (CLPP) Comments PDF 12.1.16
Dallas Burtraw and William Shobe Comments PDF 12.1.16
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) Comments PDF 12.1.16
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) Additional Comments PDF 12.23.16
Green for All Member Comments (87 Members) PDF 12.1.16
ICIS Comments PDF 12.16.16
Joint Comments (29 Organizations) PDF 12.1.16
Joint Comments (145 Outdoor Enthusiasts) PDF 12.1.16
Joint Comments (26 Outdoor Enthusiasts) PDF 12.16.16
Joint Comments on Bioenergy (14 Organizations) PDF 12.1.16
Mercuria Energy America, Inc. Comments PDF 12.1.16
New England Chapter of Environmental Entrepreneurs (E2) Comments PDF 12.1.16
New York State Senators Comments (16 Senators) PDF 12.1.16
Sierra Club Member Comments (802 Members) PDF 12.1.16
Sierra Club Petition (4,713 Signatories) PDF 12.1.16
University of Maryland Public Policy Student Comments (4 Masters' Degree Candidates) PDF 12.1.16
Vitol, Inc. Comments PDF 12.1.16

 

Jun. 17, 2016 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
Advanced Energy Economy Institute (AEEI) Comments PDF 6.29.16
Allan Straughan Comments PDF 9.21.16
Ceres Business for Innovative Climate and Energy Policy (BICEP) Comments (73 Businesses) PDF 8.24.16
Ceres Comments (21 Investors) PDF 8.24.16
Collaborative for RGGI Progress Comments PDF 6.29.16
Collaborative for RGGI Progress Comments (Additional) PDF 9.21.16
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) Comments PDF 6.29.16
Joint Comments (21 Environmental and Health Organizations) PDF 6.29.16
Joint Comments (162 Health Professionals) PDF 8.24.16
Joint Comments (15 Maine Businesses) PDF 9.21.16
Noble Americas Gas and Power Comments PDF 8.24.16
Maryland Legislator Comments (32 Legislators) PDF 8.24.16
Maryland Environmental Health Network Comments PDF 9.21.16
Reece Benson Comments PDF 9.21.16
Waterkeepers Chesapeake and Maryland Environmental Health Network Comments PDF 6.29.16

 

Apr. 29, 2016 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
AEEI and NECEC Comments PDF 5.18.16
Center for Resource Solutions (CRS) Comments PDF 5.18.16
Ceres Business for Innovative Climate and Energy Policy (BICEP) Comments PDF 5.18.16
Chesapeake Physicians for Social Responsibility Comments PDF 6.6.16
Collaborative for RGGI Progress Comments PDF 5.23.16
Dynegy Comments PDF 5.18.16
New England Chapter of Environmental Entrepreneurs (E2) Comments PDF 5.18.16
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) Comments PDF 5.27.16
Environmental Energy Alliance of New York (EEANY) White Paper PDF 6.6.16
Harvard Law School Environmental Law Program Comments PDF 5.18.16
Joint Comments (17 Environmental and Health Organizations) PDF 5.18.16
Leland Cheung (Cambridge City Councilor) Comments PDF 5.18.16
Louise Diamond Committee Comments PDF 5.18.16
Maryland Business Comments (18 Businesses) PDF 5.27.16
Maryland Legislator Comments (22 Legislators) PDF 5.27.16
NRDC Comments PDF 5.18.16
National Consumer Law Center (NCLC) Comments PDF 5.18.16
Pace Energy and Climate Center Comments PDF 5.18.16
Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) Comments PDF 5.18.16
Sierra Club Member Comments (529 members) PDF 5.18.16
Sierra Club Petitions (7,446 signatories) PDF 5.18.16
Vermont Energy Investment Corporation (VEIC) Comments PDF 5.18.16
Western Power Trading Forum (WPTF) Comments PDF 5.18.16

 

Feb. 2, 2016 Stakeholder Meeting

Format Released
American Carbon Registry Comments PDF 2.24.16
CarbonCure Comments PDF 3.16.16
Chad Tolman Comments PDF 2.24.16
Chesapeake Physicians for Social Responsibility Comments PDF 2.24.16
City of New York, Mayor's Office of Sustainability Comments PDF 2.29.16
Collaborative for RGGI Progress Comments PDF 2.24.16
Con Edison and Orange and Rockland Utilities Comments PDF 2.24.16
Core Metrics Comments PDF 2.24.16
Dynegy Comments PDF 2.24.16
EDF Comments PDF 2.24.16
Elizabeth Siftar Comments PDF 2.24.16
Entergy Comments PDF 2.24.16
Environment America Federation Comments PDF 2.24.16
Environmental Energy Alliance of NY (EEANY) Comments PDF 3.8.16
Joint Comments (16 Environmental Organizations) PDF 3.8.16
Joint Comments (23 Environmental and Health Organizations) PDF 2.24.16
Joint Comments (Center for Biological Diversity, Clean Air Task Force, and Partnership for Policy Integrity) PDF 2.24.16
Joint Comments (MAREC, RENEW Northeast, and ACE NY) PDF 2.24.16
Joint Comments (Sierra Club, Pace Energy and Climate Center, Environment America, and Acadia Center) PDF 2.24.16
MJ Bradley & Associates (MJB&A) Comments PDF 2.24.16
National Biodiesel Board (NBB) Comments PDF 2.24.16
NRDC Comments PDF 2.24.16
NRDC Additional Comments PDF 3.16.16
Sierra Club and Pace Energy and Climate Center Comments PDF 2.24.16
Sierra Club Member Comments (130 members) PDF 2.24.16
Sierra Club Petition (2,490 Signatories) PDF 2.24.16
Sierra Club Supplemental Report PDF 3.16.16
Sierra Club Vermont Chapter Comments PDF 2.24.16
The Nature Conservancy Comments PDF 2.24.16

 

Nov. 17, 2015 Stakeholder Meeting: Written Comments

Format Released
Acadia Center Comments PDF 12.8.15
Biomass Power Association Comments PDF 12.8.15
BP Comments PDF 12.8.15
Brookfield Renewable Energy Group Comments PDF 12.8.15
Calpine Corporation Comments PDF 12.8.15
The Climate Trust Comments PDF 12.8.15
Con Edison and Orange and Rockland Utilities PDF 12.8.15
Dynegy Comments PDF 12.8.15
Emera Energy Comments PDF 12.8.15
Environment America Federation Comments PDF 12.8.15
Exelon Comments PDF 12.8.15
Independent Power Producers of NY (IPPNY) Comments PDF 12.8.15
Joint Comments (26 non-profit organizations) PDF 12.8.15
Joint Comments (AEEI, ACE NY, and NECEC) PDF 12.8.15
Ken Grossman Comments PDF 12.8.15
NY Independent System Operator (NYISO) Comments PDF 12.8.15
NRDC Comments PDF 12.15.15
NRG Comments PDF 12.15.15
Pace Energy and Climate Center Comments PDF 12.8.15
RENEW Northeast Comments PDF 12.8.15
Sierra Club Comments PDF 12.8.15
Sierra Club Member Comments (48 members) PDF 12.8.15
Sierra Club Petition (2,404 signatories) PDF 12.8.15
TransCanada Comments PDF 12.15.15
Vermont Energy Investment Corporation Comments PDF 12.8.15
Wiltrud R. Mott-Smith Comments PDF 12.8.15